Centurion: Quo Vadis?

I’ve completed the first session of playtesting for Centurion, and it went both well and poorly. It went well because the mechanic worked exactly as I expected. It went poorly because this was not enough.

Two of my playtesters are also game designers, and one made the comment that during the dice mechanic, there are many points in which dice are being removed from the resolution and each of those moments should mean something. There should be a narrative, in-game response to the process of task resolution with dice.

He was absolutely correct, but I so wished he weren’t at the time, because I was having a hard time trying to figure out how all this could work. A lot of ‘but!’ came into my head and a few made it to my tongue.

Not to worry, as there were still six people around the table, and brainstorming ensued. This led to a new interpretation of the task resolution system, one in which each action during task resolution has an in-game component.

The biggest stumbling block so far is group involvement in a single task. Right now, all task resolution is dice vs. dice, as in the GM rolls dice that reflect the difficulty of a challenge against a player rolling dice for a character. When a group tries, for example, to find a single individual or accomplish some other task that is a single challenge, the number of dice used by the group overwhelms the challenge, but adding in extra dice to compensate for the number of characters inflates the challenge ridiculously.

Still working on that and we’ve scheduled another playtest session, so hopefully we’ll soon have a group challenge mechanic. Right now, I’m using “number of successes,” but it doesn’t feel right as it is totally removed from the main task resolution mechanic.

In case you are interested, you can find the original playtest rules here, and the new playtest rules here.

And the post title refers to the Latin for “where are you going?” rather than the novel and movie by the same name.

This entry was posted in RPGs and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to Centurion: Quo Vadis?

  1. The Warden says:

    What if group challenges required a single “leader” and other players to assist? Assistants can only offer up a single Quality to increase the leader’s roll by 1d6. Or something similar. The concept leans itself towards a military-type group/campaign.

  2. Fraser says:

    That was one idea I had. There’d be a “focus” character, and each other character could provide a single die, but the die could be built using smaller dice, so if one could assemble 8d6, one could provide 1d12.

    That’s the temp solution, but I fear that it will quickly overwhelm even the hardest of challenges.

  3. The Warden says:

    Only one way to find out. 🙂

  4. Walt says:

    Nothing to worry about. With two game designers at the table and both Sword Noir and Kiss My Axe a fun time at the table… This should be no problem.

    Regards,
    Walt

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.