About a week ago, I ran another session for the playtest of Intervention, my current work-in-progress—a cyberpunk TTRPG that is roll-low and semi-complex. Unlike the first iteration of playtesting, this iteration is in-person. It doesn’t change how the game plays, but it sure changes how the game is played.
What does that mean? It means that the system performs the same virtually or in-person, but the activity of playing the system is significantly changed. Further, there is marked difference between playing in public or in private.

And this is based solely on my experience. What I have seen with the playtest conforms with my general experience with virtual vs. in-person gaming, but all that experience included me—which might be a factor—and was interpreted through my perceptions.
Specifically, for Intervention, the virtual playtests had moments of humour and player (rather than character) conversations, but most of the socializing happened as the group joined the call and then after the session ended. That is not to say there was nothing during the game itself, but it was minor. The gaming was very focused on the game and the system. During in-person games, the personal tangents happen more frequently: that is to say a comment or situation is much more likely to lead to a conversation that moves away from the game and into straight up personal interaction. That’s non-game socializing happening during game time.
That’s not bad. I don’t want you to think I am upset about this. These are all people I know well, whom I like, and I am as much as fault as any of them. This is simply an observation that interested me.
Even more, the last session I ran was the first session in this second iteration of testing (the beta testing?) that happened “in private.” I held the session in my home, in my little games room, whereas I ran previous sessions at Level One Game Pub in Ottawa. I have too little data to make a definitive judgement, but I’m going to anyway.
This last iteration was like the games I remember from pre-COVID, after which so much of my gaming went virtual. It was so much more like previous “friend-group” games and playtests. The socialization was the dominant theme of the game. For this one session, that could have been the situation—we might have all been “in a mood” or ready for company rather than ready for a game—but it did really conform to the general pattern of my games from my university days to the end of 2019.
We got so little done, so very little, but it was very enjoyable. Yes, I want to stress test the game and see if some of the smaller pieces are ready for prime time (alpha playtesting showed the system itself does the job, this is about digging deeper). I also want to have fun and make sure my playtesters had fun as well. And they did. We all did.
Did I get some good data out of the last session? Not really. Did I find it valuable. Oh god yes.
Gaming—for me—has always been about socializing. When I went to conventions, I went to meet my friends and game with them. At first, there were some games with strangers, but mostly it was meeting people I knew that I only saw at conventions, and gaming with them. My home games often took the place of “going out.” So much of the time was spent socializing outside of the actual playing of the game.
There are many benefits to TTRPGs, but I think socializing has got to be near the top. Whatever else they are good for, and whatever other types of fun they provide, the chance to socialize with good people is top of the pyramid for me.
One of the playtesters asked me the next day about the session. Was it a waste? I asked them if they had fun. “Oh god yes” I told them I did too, so it was definitely not a waste. It’s the entire point of the game.
